[問卦] 新聞挖挖哇有一個來賓說三小時可以救人 - 土木

Todd Johnson avatar
By Todd Johnson
at 2010-04-27T00:04

Table of Contents

※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板]

作者: krajicek (回憶比真實精彩) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [問卦] 新聞挖挖哇有一個來賓說三小時可以救人
時間: Mon Apr 26 23:31:59 2010

不知道有沒有朋友也看到剛才那段,有一個土木技師工會的理事長說北二高這種
情況,可以考慮調幾台大型或軍事推土機,先把土往旁邊推開,然後再用怪手挖
,而且說這樣子大概只需要三個多小時就可以把土推開準備挖掘救人了。

並且他還說他打電話給交通次長反應建議他去做。

請問真的有這種方法可行嗎?為何從昨天到現在,都沒有其他的專家反應過這種
方法呢?


==========以上原文==========

有前輩能提供一些意見嗎!?

--
Tags: 土木

All Comments

Thomas avatar
By Thomas
at 2010-04-28T17:16
聽他在.... xxxx 那種重機上不了國道.
Margaret avatar
By Margaret
at 2010-04-30T09:07
說比做容易阿 你不知道嗎?
就跟唸書一樣 說要唸書 但是實際上還是上PTT阿
Ursula avatar
By Ursula
at 2010-05-03T23:20
用嘴砲轟山丘最快了
Charlie avatar
By Charlie
at 2010-05-05T22:03
哪個土有多重 知道嗎?
Zora avatar
By Zora
at 2010-05-07T08:20
嘴砲卡緊!
Agatha avatar
By Agatha
at 2010-05-10T16:54
三小時?為啥我剛聽到他是說一天?
Rae avatar
By Rae
at 2010-05-11T04:59
嘴砲也信
Carol avatar
By Carol
at 2010-05-11T15:23
嘴砲的機會較大
Ethan avatar
By Ethan
at 2010-05-12T11:57
其實我一直覺得那幾十台挖土機是演給SNG車看的...
Olive avatar
By Olive
at 2010-05-13T22:14
我有看到 他說用D8推土機去推 有沒有D8的八卦?
Madame avatar
By Madame
at 2010-05-14T17:36
嘴砲最厲害
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2010-05-15T18:07
這種你也信
Olive avatar
By Olive
at 2010-05-17T04:10
留二到三公尺的土 以上都用推土機推
Madame avatar
By Madame
at 2010-05-17T15:16
那種土量 是要往哪邊推開阿...
Christine avatar
By Christine
at 2010-05-21T20:15
嘴砲等級不輸鄉民耶
Sarah avatar
By Sarah
at 2010-05-24T03:41
用嘴巴推土最快了你都不知道 傻傻的
Steve avatar
By Steve
at 2010-05-27T09:30
沒自己去做都是嘴砲
Damian avatar
By Damian
at 2010-05-30T19:04
其實用推的會比現在堆積木式的方法快一點
John avatar
By John
at 2010-06-03T20:53
剩一張嘴 E04
Wallis avatar
By Wallis
at 2010-06-04T13:46
發正念救人
Quintina avatar
By Quintina
at 2010-06-09T08:44
那大家都去賣雞排 開大車 賺大錢了阿 你看多好賺阿
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2010-06-13T07:54
他屌他去開阿,愛嘴砲
Carolina Franco avatar
By Carolina Franco
at 2010-06-15T23:54
我用我的嘴炮三秒鐘就把土方吹到天上去
Charlie avatar
By Charlie
at 2010-06-18T08:13
土一壓下來,其實機會就很渺茫了,聽他在鬼扯
Rebecca avatar
By Rebecca
at 2010-06-22T22:26
以為是小土堆嗎 一點常識都沒有 你乾脆叫小叮噹幫你
Poppy avatar
By Poppy
at 2010-06-25T05:09
嘴砲吧......
Callum avatar
By Callum
at 2010-06-29T22:35
這理事長....難道擁有阿姆斯壯家代代相傳的...
Carol avatar
By Carol
at 2010-07-01T00:19
名嘴拿出手杖 土堆就自己開了
Candice avatar
By Candice
at 2010-07-05T11:19
===============用嘴巴救更厲害 只需要三秒================
Carol avatar
By Carol
at 2010-07-06T01:23
匯集立法委員在山丘邊一起張嘴集氣...
James avatar
By James
at 2010-07-06T16:46
都當理事長了 不知平時有沒有在從事實務
Isabella avatar
By Isabella
at 2010-07-11T05:33
他們說用D8 D9推土機 還說這個推土機民間軍隊都有
Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2010-07-15T14:13
墮落的共和,已經沒有人知道原力了....
Gilbert avatar
By Gilbert
at 2010-07-17T19:22
只出一張嘴
Skylar Davis avatar
By Skylar Davis
at 2010-07-20T19:56
嘴砲最快~~~
Freda avatar
By Freda
at 2010-07-24T19:27
其實我也覺得挖土機真的是在挖屍體~推土才有機會救人
Ophelia avatar
By Ophelia
at 2010-07-27T01:44
你知道埋那嗎?也許就在旁邊 還冒然先把土往旁邊推開.
Margaret avatar
By Margaret
at 2010-07-30T09:46
叫孫悟空用龜派氣功隨便轟一發就可以了
Victoria avatar
By Victoria
at 2010-08-01T04:51
哈哈哈 召喚兩個鄉民去砲個兩發比較時在啦
Andy avatar
By Andy
at 2010-08-02T03:27
有這麼容易就好了 乾脆叫柏油去不更快?
Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2010-08-04T01:29
紅姨也說雙英辯論救了很多人...
Kama avatar
By Kama
at 2010-08-04T03:05
交通部長:你沒聽我說冰櫃準備好了嗎?救出來是要浪費公堂泥
Elma avatar
By Elma
at 2010-08-06T21:39
怎麼不乾脆召喚變型金剛最快
Regina avatar
By Regina
at 2010-08-09T21:50
嘴砲最快拉 不用1小時就可以挖出來了
Ida avatar
By Ida
at 2010-08-11T02:05
用C4..........(被拖走
Zenobia avatar
By Zenobia
at 2010-08-15T05:43
乾脆請一頁書來 還可以把山移回去
Mia avatar
By Mia
at 2010-08-16T12:37
哇哇哇 比八卦板還嘴砲
Ethan avatar
By Ethan
at 2010-08-20T22:23
嘴炮誰不會
Bethany avatar
By Bethany
at 2010-08-24T03:39
講智這個話的是土木技師工會理事長
Puput avatar
By Puput
at 2010-08-26T22:10
嘴砲 變型金剛出動
Hazel avatar
By Hazel
at 2010-08-30T08:51
他怎麼不說用龍珠許願只要三秒
Belly avatar
By Belly
at 2010-09-02T04:50
怕的是推開土堆,旁邊的高土堆會再淹過來
Ida avatar
By Ida
at 2010-09-04T11:24
突發奇想 用動物如何? 地鼠,兔子,放個幾百隻下去打地洞
Hamiltion avatar
By Hamiltion
at 2010-09-06T14:01
怎嚜推 你說阿!? 愚公移山還是你是大力丸!!?
Charlie avatar
By Charlie
at 2010-09-07T05:58
說句不重聽的.. 很少車子可以被壓在下面還撐的住吧.
Mason avatar
By Mason
at 2010-09-07T15:55
去大都叫張無忌來嘛 他會乾坤大挪移欸
Bethany avatar
By Bethany
at 2010-09-12T12:33
學學愚公吧 光說不練
Agatha avatar
By Agatha
at 2010-09-17T03:00
我比較好奇 坦克上高速公路會怎麼樣?
Una avatar
By Una
at 2010-09-18T04:14
我只要三分鐘, 不過需要外星人的幫忙
Puput avatar
By Puput
at 2010-09-21T06:07
如果戳到人咧
Eartha avatar
By Eartha
at 2010-09-24T19:53
出來吧 地鼠!
Candice avatar
By Candice
at 2010-09-25T07:19
台灣高官沒那麼笨啦 ~~~專家一堆~~你想的到他想不到???
Hardy avatar
By Hardy
at 2010-09-28T05:05
大概是叫狂派的大力神去吧。XD
Mia avatar
By Mia
at 2010-09-30T19:12
地心毀滅那台鑽地機器 台灣有沒有阿?
Selena avatar
By Selena
at 2010-10-03T18:00
人家是技師工會理事長 鄉民只能躲在背後噓 當然鄉民是對得
John avatar
By John
at 2010-10-05T05:25
召喚摩西來直接把土堆分開好了
Frederic avatar
By Frederic
at 2010-10-06T21:08
乾脆說叫悟空用元氣玉炸開比較快
Audriana avatar
By Audriana
at 2010-10-07T10:45
北七
Daph Bay avatar
By Daph Bay
at 2010-10-12T07:10
把土推開 =>我一秒就念完了
Tristan Cohan avatar
By Tristan Cohan
at 2010-10-16T19:23
當場美鳳姐應該出動劍齒虎來挖最快
Kama avatar
By Kama
at 2010-10-19T05:16
北七捨...埋在哪都不知道了 三小時最好找的到
David avatar
By David
at 2010-10-23T15:44
XDDD
Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2010-10-24T15:30
TVBX的來賓把FTA唸成TFA還覆唱一次~講的頭頭是道~天份好
來賓上電視台 基本上都是嘴砲多~
Mia avatar
By Mia
at 2010-10-29T00:32
新勁戰騎過去可能土方會自動分開吧
John avatar
By John
at 2010-11-02T14:01
給他讀書讀假的....你老師和妳媽不會難過嗎
Odelette avatar
By Odelette
at 2010-11-06T20:31
大家都心知肚明吧 被壓到應該就沒救了 只是希望有奇蹟
Oliver avatar
By Oliver
at 2010-11-10T10:03
克勞德五秒鐘可以招喚巴哈姆特都沒拿來說嘴了
Vanessa avatar
By Vanessa
at 2010-11-10T12:40
先把土往旁邊推開? 要如何解決側向土壓力???
Audriana avatar
By Audriana
at 2010-11-12T00:11
你推土的時候本來沒被夾死的也被你擠死了
Blanche avatar
By Blanche
at 2010-11-16T23:14
用講的都很快 氣死人啦
Iris avatar
By Iris
at 2010-11-19T00:30
推老木 4 5層還連續體
Ophelia avatar
By Ophelia
at 2010-11-20T00:41
大力神用吸的最快
Kristin avatar
By Kristin
at 2010-11-20T12:49
用龍破斬會不會比較快? 黃昏よりも昏きもの....
Caroline avatar
By Caroline
at 2010-11-21T03:20
為何不找X教授來探測一下被埋在哪裡
Valerie avatar
By Valerie
at 2010-11-23T20:24
那位理事長還說中山高當年他有參與監工
Ivy avatar
By Ivy
at 2010-11-26T01:08
請用大地斬
Dora avatar
By Dora
at 2010-11-27T17:06
那種重量 柯博文來都挖不開了
Quanna avatar
By Quanna
at 2010-11-29T19:12
叫愛德華來施展鍊金術
Rebecca avatar
By Rebecca
at 2010-12-01T04:14
乾脆用龍捲風產生器 把土捲一捲好了
Donna avatar
By Donna
at 2010-12-03T02:51
幹.......................快幫我call摩西
Lydia avatar
By Lydia
at 2010-12-05T22:33
這來賓是美少女夢工廠裡的地底國王子嗎...
Carolina Franco avatar
By Carolina Franco
at 2010-12-06T11:50
20萬噸加重力加速度被壓到.....用火藥或大砲炸開最快
Kristin avatar
By Kristin
at 2010-12-10T16:36
土木技師公會會長不至於上電視亂扯來砸自己招牌吧
Lily avatar
By Lily
at 2010-12-15T06:49
你是要清土堆還是要救人?
Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2010-12-18T07:08
一壓下來就沒救了 大家不想講實話而已
Mary avatar
By Mary
at 2010-12-22T10:05
.....ZZZZZ 人家挖了一兩天挖不出來 你挖三小時就OK了Y
Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2010-12-22T18:47
對歐 怎麼沒想到 趕快跟小叮噹借土撥鼠手套
Una avatar
By Una
at 2010-12-23T07:34
........
Doris avatar
By Doris
at 2010-12-24T22:28
為什麼沒有人發明一種大型吸塵器 可以先把碎沙吸光
Cara avatar
By Cara
at 2010-12-27T20:14
我也蠻懷疑 這樣的內行人 這樣的發言這底是不是合理的?
Kristin avatar
By Kristin
at 2010-12-31T14:31
叫項羽用冬雷霹靂開路比較快
Linda avatar
By Linda
at 2011-01-03T03:19
用"地心毀滅"的那台機器 大概一秒
Frederica avatar
By Frederica
at 2011-01-06T00:17
上面有不平還有石樹
Agatha avatar
By Agatha
at 2011-01-10T00:11
其實冰櫃最有可能 但是太殘忍...交通部長不能講 =_=
Kama avatar
By Kama
at 2011-01-10T18:48
叫衛生紙使徒來挖算 一發清光土堆
Xanthe avatar
By Xanthe
at 2011-01-14T16:22
那位理事長剛講某位立委擋了地質法,請問是誰??
Cara avatar
By Cara
at 2011-01-16T06:57
========= 小滴,快把死魚魚吸塵器拿出來吃泥巴 ========
Queena avatar
By Queena
at 2011-01-18T22:11
土木技師公會會長應該不會亂扯,底下會員都在看
Agnes avatar
By Agnes
at 2011-01-20T21:43
rinsoukan跟幻影旅團借就有了
Oscar avatar
By Oscar
at 2011-01-20T22:46
如果只是清土堆的話,他這樣講不過份,可是要救人耶
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2011-01-24T22:30
鄉民都不知道有沒有他的專業..
Dora avatar
By Dora
at 2011-01-27T13:43
>bla 對啊!我也有聽到 旁邊的主持人和來賓假裝耳聾嗎?
William avatar
By William
at 2011-01-31T17:12
可惜台灣沒有該屬性的念能力者......
Margaret avatar
By Margaret
at 2011-02-04T22:59
Irma avatar
By Irma
at 2011-02-09T05:18
我也想知道是誰擋的~真該死
Hedda avatar
By Hedda
at 2011-02-11T11:34
要是車子被挖出來時有一半是被挖爛的,準備被罵臭頭了
James avatar
By James
at 2011-02-13T02:05
他說的不是清土堆 是在說救人 先把上層的土推掉 再用挖的
Leila avatar
By Leila
at 2011-02-13T10:55
先把土往旁邊推開?
George avatar
By George
at 2011-02-17T07:11
唉...堆土機說不訂可以試...是要保握黃金72小時
Genevieve avatar
By Genevieve
at 2011-02-18T14:13
他說的3小時是推土機數量夠多吧,不可能是一兩台
Jake avatar
By Jake
at 2011-02-22T03:05
http://ppt.cc/~v9D D8
Rachel avatar
By Rachel
at 2011-02-25T06:48
現在看起來像是要救人的樣子嗎?
Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2011-03-01T16:15
他不說3小時能救 難道要說政府已經很快了麼?
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2011-03-06T02:39
好像是推到3公尺再挖
Annie avatar
By Annie
at 2011-03-06T05:32
現在這樣 給他兩個月都還挖不完 現在是在玩樂高嗎?
Michael avatar
By Michael
at 2011-03-10T19:30
就算可以推 也要施力點吧 而且這種車車不小台
Annie avatar
By Annie
at 2011-03-13T02:36
乾脆把土往記者和名嘴那邊推
John avatar
By John
at 2011-03-17T08:33
而且他也說,高速公路是用推土機開的,那用推土機挖清土應
Hamiltion avatar
By Hamiltion
at 2011-03-21T15:32
台灣真的有些屌機器能用吧....只是我看沒人敢去負責
Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2011-03-25T14:48
把土挖到上面 再從上面推下來 再挖到卡車裡...
Elvira avatar
By Elvira
at 2011-03-29T10:31
該是比挖土機更好的方法
Genevieve avatar
By Genevieve
at 2011-03-30T03:52
這種工法應該是為了保障司機們的安全吧??
Yedda avatar
By Yedda
at 2011-03-31T12:46
大部分的官阿 應該都跟這邊的酸民一樣自己腦補一堆藉口
而不去找人來研究可行性~
Joseph avatar
By Joseph
at 2011-04-02T15:25
很簡單 推不動
Aaliyah avatar
By Aaliyah
at 2011-04-05T19:27
土木技師工會 怎樣也比鄉民專業
Yuri avatar
By Yuri
at 2011-04-07T21:05
真的有辦法就不會只當名嘴了
Anthony avatar
By Anthony
at 2011-04-09T07:12
不挖到卡車裡......難道把高速公路填平嗎.....
Emma avatar
By Emma
at 2011-04-10T15:38
土龍攻?
Quintina avatar
By Quintina
at 2011-04-13T07:41
本來也想po這個的 http://tinyurl.com/2d4xw76 不只他建議
Heather avatar
By Heather
at 2011-04-15T10:11
現在應該是要先把人車找到 土晚點運沒關係
Catherine avatar
By Catherine
at 2011-04-18T19:09
填平也好啊,反正也不能通了,趕快救人要緊
Necoo avatar
By Necoo
at 2011-04-19T09:42
他又不是名嘴...他是技師公會理事長
Lauren avatar
By Lauren
at 2011-04-22T21:40
不好意思 蔡主席說 只有台灣智庫才是專家 其他都不是
Heather avatar
By Heather
at 2011-04-23T02:30
既然來賓有打電話 他有說交通部次長怎麼回應嗎...
Ursula avatar
By Ursula
at 2011-04-25T02:21
說句不該說的 也許在上位者真正想的是把路搶通而已
Gary avatar
By Gary
at 2011-04-27T22:53
這麼會講 怎不請科博文來搬土比較快 他媽出那張嘴誰不會
Hedy avatar
By Hedy
at 2011-05-02T18:15
鄉民只會說嘴 連技師一半的毛都摸不倒吧
Quanna avatar
By Quanna
at 2011-05-03T14:46
好像是說會反映給相關單位處理
Lucy avatar
By Lucy
at 2011-05-06T08:01
一堆鄉民好像很強都懂..
Gary avatar
By Gary
at 2011-05-07T02:13
技師公會裡的技師都是高手 難道會比鄉民弱?只會說嘴?
Skylar DavisLinda avatar
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2011-05-07T16:22
不懂的鄉民就別說嘴 外行指導內行
Kyle avatar
By Kyle
at 2011-05-11T09:03
鄉民最厲害就是打嘴砲阿 不然呢XD
Catherine avatar
By Catherine
at 2011-05-13T04:36
全台學土木沒有萬也有千這招就他一個想的到別人都想不到?
Una avatar
By Una
at 2011-05-14T18:14
鄉民們認為不可能的根據是什麼? 又不是專業人士真的懂?
Emily avatar
By Emily
at 2011-05-15T15:23
乾脆呼叫克拉克肯特好了
Queena avatar
By Queena
at 2011-05-17T03:51
鄉民:我打嘴砲的啦~ 林北學電機的只會用FET推土
Ophelia avatar
By Ophelia
at 2011-05-20T17:00
鄉民出張嘴說不可能最快啦
Ethan avatar
By Ethan
at 2011-05-23T10:28
這是D9推土機 http://ppt.cc/pdrW
Agnes avatar
By Agnes
at 2011-05-25T16:07
============嘴砲還要三個小時 有點弱喔 =============
Eden avatar
By Eden
at 2011-05-30T09:35
應該前面推文連結 要有夠大的運作面積 大石頭要先清除
Gilbert avatar
By Gilbert
at 2011-05-31T18:16
不懂也可以批評,鄉民果然是登入就變專家的最佳典範XD
Rosalind avatar
By Rosalind
at 2011-06-02T06:55
才有辦法推土吧?
Ingrid avatar
By Ingrid
at 2011-06-06T11:08
推土需要有迴轉的地方 而且目前土堆比推土機高好幾倍
Faithe avatar
By Faithe
at 2011-06-09T01:08
該頻道有鋼彈
Todd Johnson avatar
By Todd Johnson
at 2011-06-13T10:10
現場有沒有辦法支撐這種大型機具 沒有的話去也是白去
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2011-06-16T16:00
綠吱吱的嘴炮 跟他不分上下...
Emily avatar
By Emily
at 2011-06-19T22:11
而且土質不知道會不會太鬆軟 萬一推一推自己也...
Ivy avatar
By Ivy
at 2011-06-24T07:51
就算挖出一條縫了 推土機能進去左右比它高的土堆內作業嗎
Leila avatar
By Leila
at 2011-06-28T03:10
有沒有連結!?我明天問教授!!!
Hardy avatar
By Hardy
at 2011-06-28T14:15
那不如放台TBM好了
Agatha avatar
By Agatha
at 2011-06-30T20:42
挖出一條縫 土壤會有側向土壓力 往內崩塌 掩埋 科科
Christine avatar
By Christine
at 2011-07-03T04:35
他兩點會重播啦
Delia avatar
By Delia
at 2011-07-03T19:31
爆三小時!!那種很大台的到現場光是組裝就快一天了!!
Tristan Cohan avatar
By Tristan Cohan
at 2011-07-03T23:47
推土機就算能裝料也很不方便迴轉吧...
Poppy avatar
By Poppy
at 2011-07-07T14:03
推土機將土推向邊坡,等於讓山上災害搶修時的陋習
Donna avatar
By Donna
at 2011-07-09T17:34
多餘的土推落山谷,造成山下日後的二度災害,活生生
Lucy avatar
By Lucy
at 2011-07-14T05:01
在SNG鏡頭前上演,但為了救人,這似乎也是不得不的手段
Donna avatar
By Donna
at 2011-07-18T17:29
算一下土壤覆土壓力 哪一台車頂可以撐住土石不變形

北二高走山

Hamiltion avatar
By Hamiltion
at 2010-04-26T19:49
※ 引述《takubon (阿土哥)》之銘言: : 一堆人問我這件事的看法(因為我是單位裡唯一的土木系) : 我的解釋是and#34;順向坡動坡腳 擋土牆如果做不好 走�� ...

台大土木CAE組 誠徵兼任研究助理一名

Christine avatar
By Christine
at 2010-04-26T14:36
台大土木系電腦輔助工程實驗室 誠徵兼任研究助理一至兩名 台大土木系電腦輔助工程實驗室誠徵工讀人員一至兩名, 協助數值模擬和數據分析等事 ...

北二高走山

Isabella avatar
By Isabella
at 2010-04-26T09:08
一堆人問我這件事的看法(因為我是單位裡唯一的土木系) 我的解釋是and#34;順向坡動坡腳 擋土牆如果做不好 走山是早晚的事and#34; 這樣合理嗎 請�� ...

徵願意割愛實力2000元折價券的版友(高雄)

Eartha avatar
By Eartha
at 2010-04-26T00:59
as title 4月28日要去報名了高雄班 所以上來徵一下實力2000元的折價券 如果住高雄的版友你手邊有多餘用不到的 願意割愛的話 你覺得價值多少可�� ...

請問誰有透地雷達

Tristan Cohan avatar
By Tristan Cohan
at 2010-04-25T23:48
麻煩趕緊送到國道3號3.1公里處發生山壁崩落處 探勘挖掘路線 --